Bitcoin owner Peter Schiff has raised alarms about Bitcoin for years, repeatedly arguing that investors are better off sticking with traditional safe-haven assets like gold and silver.
One of the most outspoken crypto skeptics, Schiff has consistently dismissed Bitcoin’s long-term value proposition while defending precious metals as the ultimate store of wealth.
As Schiff lambasted Bitcoin, it repeatedly outperformed both gold and silver by a wide margin, delivering returns that left the metals behind and forcing even the harshest critics to contend with crypto’s brutal rise.
However, after the recent surge, silver has now outperformed Bitcoin since early 2021.
While Bitcoin is still crushing the entire period from 2018 to date, the difference comes down to the regime, the timing, and the type of pain you can actually endure.
Each cycle has its characteristic subject, in 2021 it felt obvious.
Bitcoin had the story, the momentum, the cultural gravitas, and the kind of upside that made everything else seem slow. Many people bought it as a statement as well as an investment, and for a while it seemed like the cleanest bet on the market.
Then something quieter happened.
If you bought silver in early 2021 and held on to the last weekly data point in this data set, you outperformed the Bitcoin holder.
Not a little, but a lot.
In our numbers, silver returned about 322% versus Bitcoin’s 130% over the same period, that’s roughly 193 percentage points of additional performance, and about 84% more total wealth on a comparable starting dollar.
So why did the ‘grandpa metal’ beat the hardest money on the internet, and why is Bitcoin still winning when you zoom out?
The short answer is timing, the longer answer is that the world of trading has changed.
The data and what “since 2018” and “since 2021” mean here
This analysis uses weekly data for Bitcoin, crude oil, gold, silver, S&P 500 futures and the US Dollar Index, running from May 28, 2018 Through January 26, 2026.
‘Since 2021’ begins January 4, 2021the first weekly data point after January 1.
Returns are simple percentage changes from start to finish, using the first and last available values in each period.
Returns since 2018, Bitcoin still carries the crown
Zoom out to the full window, and it will look familiar again. Bitcoin is the standout performer by a wide margin, and nothing else comes close.
| Possess | Total return |
|---|---|
| Bitcoin (BTCUSD) | +1,036.5% |
| Silver | +554.9% |
| Gold | +292.8% |
| S&P 500 futures (ES1!) | +156.2% |
| US Dollar Index (DXY) | +2.3% |
| Oil (OILUSD) | -6.8% |
That table is the reason Bitcoin became the standard benchmark for “best assets of the decade” arguments. Even after several brutal drawdowns, the compound still dominates the long lens.
It also shows something people forget when they focus solely on Bitcoin: silver wasn’t dead money in the 2018s.
It more than quintupled, all while behaving like metal, which meant it delivered the full emotional package: long, boring stretches, sudden spikes of violence, and ample opportunities to be shaken out.
Returns since January 2021, silver and gold take the lead
Now zoom in on the post-2020 world, which will be defined by inflation news, interest rate shocks and the slow realization that liquidity will not be free forever.
| Possess | Total return |
|---|---|
| Silver | +322.3% |
| Gold | +174.7% |
| Bitcoin (BTCUSD) | +129.5% |
| S&P 500 futures (ES1!) | +83.5% |
| Oil (OILUSD) | +17.2% |
| US Dollar Index (DXY) | +6.9% |
This is the split-screen moment.
Bitcoin wins the story from 2018 to now because it owned the early part of the decade, when the world was steeped in liquidity and risk appetite, and when the cryptocurrency adoption curve was at its steepest.
Silver and gold are winning the story from 2021 to now, as the market became more concerned with the price of money and the credibility of the system, and less about pure duration and growth. Gold also had a steady tailwind from official sector buying central banks theme remains in the background even as the headlines move on.
Silver had its own mix of factors: it acts like money when fear is high, and like an industrial input when the world is building. Industrial demand linked to solarElectrification and data infrastructure have been part of the modern silver story, and this matters because the silver market is smaller and easier to circumvent.
The ‘but’ part: Silver beating Bitcoin isn’t the easy win it seems
Silver’s outperformance since the start of 2021 looks clean in a table, but experiencing it rarely feels clean.
- Silver’s fluctuations are a feature, not a bug. It’s a tighter market than gold, it can move quickly in either direction, and it has a knack for punishing anyone who thinks they can hold it the same way an index fund would.
- The entry point is more important than people admit. A January 2021 buyer saw a window where silver had room to run, and Bitcoin had already recorded a historic 2020. Shift the start date by a few months, change the story, that applies to both assets.
- Bitcoin was still doing its job. A total return of 130% over a full rate hike cycle is not a failure; it’s evidence that Bitcoin’s long-term bid has survived a hostile macro environment. The point is that the macro environment has changed the rankings.
- ‘Best return’ is not the same as ‘best hold’. The S&P 500 futures series, a stock proxy linked to the E-mini S&P 500provided a much smoother ride than metal or Bitcoin for most investors, even though it underperformed in this window.
Even the dollar, followed here as DXYplays a different game. It can dominate for a while, it is rarely as compounded as a true risk asset, and it often tells you more about global tensions than it offers you long-term returns.
What this says about the past eight years, and what it says about the next eight years
There is a human temptation in the markets to pick one winner and wear it as an identity.
Bitcoin people do it, gold people do it, stock people do it, and it works until the regime changes and the portfolio no longer matches the world.
The 2018-to-date table rewards the asset that experienced the steepest adoption curve and captured the “digital scarcity” trade of the decade.
The 2021-to-date table rewards assets that have benefited from inflation fears, central bank behavior and the realization that supply chains and industrial inputs are once again strategically important.
Neither table is the whole story, they are two snapshots from the same film.
If there’s one thing you want to know, it’s this: the question isn’t which possession is “best,” the question is what environment you’re in and whether you can hold on to the thing you bought when it stops being fun.